
If I was a sport journalist, I would be curious to know how NFL rookies are dealing with a position change. Most players are drafted to play the position they played at college. But not all of them. How does it feels to be told you’re going to change your position ?
Last year, we saw how much Steelers made a good decision when they converted Antwaan Randle El from the QB position to the WR position a few years ago. They knew what they were doing – or it turned out well.
I was curious about this year draft. OK, let’s be clear, I didn’t even intend to check if the players drafted by the 32 teams through the 7 rounds seems to play to their normal position – I don’t have that much time to waste. I only checked for the QB for the rounds 3 to 7.
Probably the biggest NFL story over the last years is how Tom Brady, a 6th round pick who also considered to play professional baseball as a receiver, step up when his team needed him to eventually win 3 Superbowls.
QB is a tough job. Maybe the toughest position of all sports. That’s why every QB rookie needs commitment from his team.
Obviously, we mostly care about first round QB. Those Vince Young, Matt Leinart, Jay Cutler… A first round QB is meant to change a team for several years. But even them needs time to get fit for the job.
If we have a look at the QB drafted at rounds 3 to 7, there’s 8 players. Most of them are already the 3rd QB of their team. Ingle Martin, 5th round, is the 4th QB at Green Bay but there might be some changes next year at this team’s position. Let’s mention that Brodie Croyle, 3rd round, is the 3rd QB for Kansas City. That’s too bad for Casey Printers, the former impressive QB of the BC Lions (CFL), he’s 4th. But Trent Green is getting old.
Two of those 8 QB drafted at rounds 3 to 7 won’t play QB.
First, Michael Robinson, 4th round. He will play running back for San Francisco. Actually, he’ll be the 4th (!) running back. When you look at his scouting report it seems the kid has some potential. He could learn behind the young Alex Smith and turn out as an nice second QB. Does the team have a plan for him ? Or it’s just show me what you got until we draft some good RB to take your job ?
Second, Reggie McNeal, 5th round, who will play as a wide receiver. Great athlete, no doubt about it, but his scouting report shows some concerns about his potential as a QB. He could be a terrific receiver. In this case it seems more like a good idea. But what about the team commitment ? He’s about the 7th or 8th WR on the depth chart. Sounds like he won’t play on the regular season. Ok, that’s not Jesus, that’s a 5th round pick, but I hope the team won’t waste his potential just because other players can do the job better right now. In the other hand, just because he played QB doesn’t mean he’s more important than a WR. But when you ask a player to play another position, it should be because you believe in his athletic abilities, not because it turns out you drafted him and you feel this way about him.